By Deep Work Club · Last updated: October 2026 · Reading time: 8 minutes
As a team lead you still heard what wasn't working. As a head of, it gets quieter, and at some point everyone just nods. Not getting honest feedback as a leader is not a sign that everything is fine. It is a well-researched side effect of power. This article explains why honest feedback for leaders dries up with every step, which two concepts describe it, and which tools bring it back: asking actively, skip-levels and peers outside your own company.
Key takeaways
The more power leaders hold, the less honest feedback they get. Fewer people sit above them, and more people below them fear consequences if they criticise.
The MUM effect (Rosen & Tesser, 1970) describes people's reluctance to deliver bad news. Towards a boss, it gets stronger.
Senior leaders rate themselves more favourably than the people around them do. In an analysis by Fabio Sala this held for 19 of 20 competencies measured.
In our work with leaders and chiefs of staff, we hear again and again that they lack sparring at eye level: someone who reflects back honestly and doesn't depend on their judgement.
Leaders who actively ask for critical feedback are rated as more effective (Ashford & Tsui, 1991). Honest feedback doesn't arrive by itself. You have to organise it.
Why do leaders get less honest feedback the higher they rise?
Leaders get less honest feedback with every promotion because two things happen at once: fewer people above you can assess you openly, and more people below you depend on your judgement. Criticism travelling upwards becomes riskier, and most people would rather stay quiet than expose themselves. The silence grows with the title.
Organisational psychologist Tasha Eurich names exactly these two reasons in Harvard Business Review: senior leaders simply have fewer people above them who can give candid feedback. And the more power someone holds, the less comfortable others feel offering criticism, because they fear it will hurt their careers.
Many leaders describe it like this:
"The further up I get, the more rarely anyone tells me openly how things are really going."
In our work with founders and leaders, missing sparring at eye level is a theme we hear again and again, from heads of just as much as from chiefs of staff.
What is the MUM effect?
The MUM effect is people's tendency not to pass on unpleasant information. Psychologists Sidney Rosen and Abraham Tesser named it in 1970, after "keeping mum". In their experiments, bad news was passed on less often than good news, even when the messenger had nothing to do with it. At work, a second layer comes on top.
Frances Milliken, Elizabeth Morrison and Patricia Hewlin interviewed employees in 2003 about what they don't raise with their bosses. Most had been in situations where they saw a problem and said nothing. The most common reason: fear of being labelled negatively and damaging valued relationships.
For you as a leader this means: silence is not agreement. It is the default, unless you do something about it.
What is "CEO disease"?
"CEO disease" is a term coined by Daniel Goleman, Richard Boyatzis and Annie McKee (Harvard Business Review, 2001). It describes leaders who barely know how their mood and behaviour land in the organisation. Their mistake: they assume someone would tell them if they were having a negative effect. According to the authors, they're wrong.
Research on self- and other-ratings backs this up. Fabio Sala compared self-assessments with ratings from bosses, peers and direct reports. Senior leaders rated themselves higher than others did on 19 of 20 competencies, more so than lower levels. The effects were small but consistent. Adam Galinsky and colleagues found in 2006, across several experiments, that power reduces people's ability to take the perspective of others. And Tasha Eurich reports from her own research programme with nearly 5,000 participants that most people believe they are self-aware, but only 10 to 15 percent actually met the criteria.
This is not a character flaw but a structural effect: if you receive fewer honest signals, you calibrate your self-image on the friendly ones that remain.
How can you tell it has gone quiet around you?
You rarely notice it directly. You notice patterns: meetings without pushback, problems you hear about late or second-hand, and feedback rounds that contain only praise. This checklist helps you look honestly.
Signal | What it can mean |
|---|---|
Your proposals almost always pass without objection | Agreeing is cheaper than disagreeing |
You only hear about problems once they've escalated | Bad news is being held back (MUM effect) |
Your last piece of critical feedback was months ago | Not because there was nothing to say |
Criticism only reaches you anonymously or indirectly | It exists, just not face to face |
You think: "If something were wrong, they'd tell me" | Exactly the assumption Goleman and colleagues refute |
A question that often lands in our work with leaders: how do you know you're doing your job well when hardly anyone gives you honest feedback anymore? If you have no quick answer, you may be doubting yourself too. More on that in the article on impostor syndrome as a leader.
How do you get honest feedback back as a leader?
You get honest feedback back by asking for it actively, specifically and regularly, by making it safe to answer, and by adding sources that don't depend on you. Three routes work best together: targeted questions to your team, skip-level conversations, and peers outside your company who have no stake in your success.
A field study by Susan Ashford and Anne Tsui (1991) with 387 managers shows why it pays off: managers who actively sought negative feedback were rated as more effective by their bosses, peers and direct reports. Elad Sherf and Elizabeth Morrison showed in 2020 why it rarely happens: people who feel highly competent tend to ask for feedback less, unless they deliberately take the other person's perspective.
Tool | How it works | What it gives you | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
Ask specifically | Instead of "Any feedback?", ask: "What's one thing I should do differently in meetings?" | A specific question lowers the bar and implies an answer is expected | Only works if you react calmly and visibly change something |
Skip-level conversations | Regular talks with your leads' reports, without the leads | You hear what gets filtered on the way up | Don't use them to police your leads; treat topics confidentially |
Anonymous upward feedback | Short survey on your leadership, two or three times a year | More candid than face to face | No dialogue, no follow-up questions |
External peers | A fixed group of leaders from other companies | Nobody depends on your judgement, everyone knows the role | They don't see your day-to-day, only your account of it |
Peers deserve a second look. Inside a company, feedback is always tied to interests. That's why some leaders turn down internal coaching: anyone in the same company always has interests of their own. External peers don't have that conflict. They recognise patterns because they sit in similar roles, and you can sanity-check surprising feedback with them before you overreact. How to give honest feedback yourself without hurting people is covered in the article on Radical Candor.
Three things for this week
Ask one specific question. In your next one-on-one, ask: "What should I know that nobody here tells me?" Then listen, say thanks, don't justify.
Close the loop. When you get feedback, tell the person two weeks later what you did with it. It's the strongest proof that honesty is safe with you.
Find one person outside. Think about who you can talk to about things you'd tell neither your team nor your CEO. If nobody comes to mind, that's the real insight.
Frequently asked questions
Why doesn't my team give me honest feedback? Because criticism travelling upwards is risky. People are reluctant to deliver bad news (the MUM effect) and fear being labelled negatively. It's usually not distrust of you personally but a pattern that grows stronger with every level of hierarchy.
What is CEO disease? A term from Goleman, Boyatzis and McKee (2001) for leaders who barely know how they come across and assume someone would tell them. In practice, that rarely happens.
What is a skip-level meeting? A conversation between a leader and the direct reports of their direct reports, without the manager in between. It helps you hear information that gets filtered on the way up. Keep your leads in the loop and don't use it as a control instrument.
Where can leaders find honest feedback outside their own company? In fixed, confidential groups with leaders from other companies, such as facilitated peer groups, or with an external coach. What matters is that nobody in the room depends on your judgement.
Is anonymous feedback more honest? Often, yes, because the risk disappears. But it doesn't replace a conversation, because you can't ask follow-up questions. Combine both: anonymous for breadth, direct and with peers for depth.
In summary
The higher you climb, the quieter it gets. That's down to structure: fewer people above you, more who depend on you, and a human tendency to hold back bad news. The result is a self-image that drifts away from how others see you. Countering it means asking actively and specifically, visibly closing the loop, and bringing in people who have no stake in your success.
In short: beyond a certain level, honest feedback is no longer a gift. It's something you have to organise.
Don't want to figure this out alone? In the Leadership Circle, up to ten leaders from Berlin startups and scale-ups meet regularly, facilitated by Lea Mersch. Book a free intro call
Sources
Ashford, S. J., & Tsui, A. S. (1991). Self-regulation for managerial effectiveness: The role of active feedback seeking. Academy of Management Journal, 34(2), 251–280. doi:10.5465/256442
Eurich, T. (2018). What self-awareness really is (and how to cultivate it). Harvard Business Review, 4 January 2018. hbr.org/2018/01/what-self-awareness-really-is-and-how-to-cultivate-it
Galinsky, A. D., Magee, J. C., Inesi, M. E., & Gruenfeld, D. H. (2006). Power and perspectives not taken. Psychological Science, 17(12), 1068–1074. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9280.2006.01824.x
Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R., & McKee, A. (2001). Primal leadership: The hidden driver of great performance. Harvard Business Review, December 2001. hbr.org/2001/12/primal-leadership-the-hidden-driver-of-great-performance
Milliken, F. J., Morrison, E. W., & Hewlin, P. F. (2003). An exploratory study of employee silence: Issues that employees don't communicate upward and why. Journal of Management Studies, 40(6), 1453–1476. doi:10.1111/1467-6486.00387
Rosen, S., & Tesser, A. (1970). On reluctance to communicate undesirable information: The MUM effect. Sociometry, 33(3), 253–263. doi:10.2307/2786156
Sala, F. (2002). It's lonely at the top: Executives' emotional intelligence self (mis)perceptions. Consortium for Research on Emotional Intelligence in Organizations. eiconsortium.org/reports/its_lonely_at_the_top_executives_ei_misperceptions.html. Published as: Sala, F. (2003). Executive blind spots: Discrepancies between self- and other-ratings. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 55(4), 222–229. doi:10.1037/1061-4087.55.4.222
Sherf, E. N., & Morrison, E. W. (2020). I do not need feedback! Or do I? Self-efficacy, perspective taking, and feedback seeking. Journal of Applied Psychology, 105(2), 146–165. doi:10.1037/apl0000432