By Deep Work Club · Last updated: October 2026 · 8 minute read
In startups it is the rule, not the exception: the first layer of management comes from within the team. Yesterday you were out for drinks with the team; today you run reviews, set expectations and may have to let a friend go. This article explains why going from peer to manager is so delicate in young teams, why closeness is not the problem but a trust credit, and where the real tension comes from. It draws on episode 9 of the Deep Talk podcast with Lea Mersch, psychologist, psychotherapist and former member of the German national basketball team, and Till Westermann.
Key takeaways
Leaders promoted from within start with a trust advantage. Research on social identity (Hogg, 2001) shows that someone seen as "one of us" gets more room for unpopular decisions, not less.
Most friendships survive the promotion: in a survey of more than 1,000 employees (ResumeLab, 2020), 69 percent said the friendship stayed the same and 14 percent said it improved.
The real hurdle is the new role. The biggest challenge for the newly promoted: establishing authority.
Tension does not come from closeness itself but from having to be friend and manager at the same time, in the same conversation.
Flat hierarchies don't solve the problem. Without formal roles, everything gets settled at the relationship level.
What does going from peer to manager mean?
Going from peer to manager is the transition from a relationship at eye level to one with formal responsibility. Before, the same rules applied to everyone. Afterwards you are the one who checks punctuality, gives feedback, runs one-on-ones, writes reviews and has a say in promotions and pay.
Lea knows this moment from basketball:
"You're an equal player on a team, and then suddenly a captain emerges. She's no longer just at eye level with everyone, she's the coach's mouthpiece. At first that's role confusion."
— Lea Mersch, Deep Talk episode 9
Till brings an example from his own circle: a friend joins as a freelance coach. Before, there was only friendship; now it is about money and results. As soon as expectations aren't met and he raises it, the conflict threatens to tip over into the relationship.
Why this happens so often in startups
In corporate settings, authority often develops more organically because promotions follow expertise, age and tenure. In a startup, everyone is usually about the same age, expertise grows on the job, and the manager emerges from the team itself.
On top of that, founding teams are strikingly homogeneous. Martin Ruef showed for the US that founding partnerships are highly similar in gender, occupation, age and ethnicity. A new study by Balázs Kovács and Tim Sels in the Strategic Management Journal goes further: across 1,125 US startups, founding teams were also far more politically alike than chance would predict, even after controlling for age, gender and industry.
Lea doesn't see this as a mistake at first, but as a strategy. Similar people decide faster with less friction. It can tip during scaling when, as Till describes, revenue targets suddenly have to be hit and you realise you need seniority: people ten or fifteen years older with real experience.
Nobody wants to be the bad guy
Till describes the obvious worry of the newly promoted:
"You still want to be part of the team, go for a beer or a run with them after work. And you don't want to be the bad guy who's always rapping people's knuckles."
— Till Westermann, Deep Talk episode 9
The intuition behind it: if you are so much "one of us", unpopular decisions should be especially hard. Research shows the opposite.
The trust advantage
Michael Hogg's social identity theory of leadership (2001) holds that leadership influence comes from being seen as especially typical of the group, as an embodiment of what the group stands for. Because that person is seen as part of the group, people trust them not to act against it.
That creates a credit. Edwin Hollander called it idiosyncrasy credit back in 1958, and Dominic Abrams and colleagues showed a related form experimentally in 2008, innovation credit: leaders seen as typical of the group get more leeway to deviate from group norms.
"You have your team's trust, because you used to be one of them. You're allowed to make unpopular decisions, too, because that's part of your job."
— Lea Mersch, Deep Talk episode 9
Lea translates it into basketball: when a captain who has played for the club for three years and is a fan favourite makes an unpopular call, it gets accepted more readily than from a new signing from the US nobody knows yet. For startups, the flip side is that an experienced manager hired from outside gets watched more critically at first than someone from the team's own ranks.
The myth of the flat hierarchy
To avoid the role problem, many startups stay flat for a long time. Lea promoted exactly that as an agile coach in consulting: fast decisions instead of formal hierarchy. Which is why one finding surprised her.
Saerom (Ronnie) Lee studied more than 6,000 video game start-ups founded between 1971 and 2015 for the Strategic Management Journal (2022). Flatter structures encouraged experimentation but were more often associated with commercial failure. The mechanism: to succeed commercially, someone eventually has to limit creative freedom and cut ideas. Without structure that rarely works.
For closeness and distance, this has an important consequence:
"When there are no formal roles, no formal hierarchy, everything gets settled at the relationship level. So the opinion leader, who may not be the expert, is the one who decides."
— Lea Mersch, Deep Talk episode 9
Till pushes back that "flat" can mean very different things, and that with AI tools many teams are now asking whether they still need team leads at all. Lea's observation from scale-ups: by around 30 people, a first management layer usually goes in, because people need orientation and someone who translates the vision into their area.
What happens to the friendship?
The fear of losing friends with a promotion is widespread. The data are more reassuring. In a 2020 survey by the career platform ResumeLab of more than 1,000 US employees, nearly 69 percent said the promotion did not change the friendship. For 14 percent it improved, for 17 percent it got worse.
The biggest challenge for the newly promoted was something else: 38 percent said establishing authority over their new reports was hardest. The friendship is more robust than expected. Exercising the role is the hard part.
Till sees an opportunity in this too: the existing relationship can develop, and that doesn't have to go in a negative direction.
Unconscious favouritism
Leader-member exchange theory (LMX) by George Graen and Mary Uhl-Bien describes how every leader develops relationships of different closeness with individual team members. Some end up in a closer in-group with more trust and leeway, others don't. That is unavoidable. Till describes how it shows up day to day:
"With some people you like going for coffee or lunch more often. And without noticing, that affects who gets which project, who gets which feedback, how formally things get communicated."
— Till Westermann, Deep Talk episode 9
Lea adds: and in the end, maybe who gets which salary. The task is not to have no closeness, but to watch yourself to minimise favouritism. Once performance is being evaluated, that matters.
How expensive unresolved closeness can get is shown by a case Lea tells. A friend of hers needed eight months to admit to herself that she had to let go of someone on her team who was also a friend. She calls it one of her biggest mistakes. What would have helped: stepping deliberately into the factual role earlier and deciding on the basis of performance. More on why these conversations get postponed in the article on difficult conversations at work.
Closeness or structure: which creates more tension?
Lea asks Till a question most readers will intuitively get wrong: is role tension higher when the relationship is closer, or when the organisation is more formal? Till's gut says: when the relationship is closer.
Kathleen Bridge and Leslie Baxter studied people with close friendships at work, so-called blended relationships, in 1992. Their surprising finding: more closeness went with less reported dual-role tension, not more.
That is not an argument against professional distance. It shifts the diagnosis. The problem is not closeness but simultaneity:
"Not closeness itself, but the simultaneity of role expectations. Basically: who am I right now? That's what created the tension, the friction."
— Lea Mersch, Deep Talk episode 9
Newer research by Marie-Colombe Afota and colleagues (2024) describes what happens when a close leader relationship turns into friendship: a blended friendship emerges in which both sides have to play two roles at once, with benefits and costs for well-being, engagement and performance. Lea's summary: complete closeness leads to role confusion in which good decisions are no longer possible. Complete distance creates an unnatural situation. The task is to separate the two deliberately.
Three tools for newly promoted leaders
1. The expectations contract
Make explicit what is expected professionally and how performance is measured, before closeness becomes habit. This is not a detail: in Gallup's Q2 2025 survey of 17,660 US employees, only 47 percent strongly agreed that they know what is expected of them at work. The clearer expectations are, the easier it is to separate later: this is about the work and about expectations that were met or not. Not about the friendship. In homogeneous teams this matters even more, because shared identity tempts people to leave assumptions unchecked.
2. Separate in time
Keep work conversations and personal conversations apart deliberately, in time as well. Work gets discussed in the office or on a call, not in your free time. Till makes it concrete for the difficult conversation:
"You say: hey, I've got this and this on the agenda today, I'd like to go through the last three months with you. And you don't start with: how's the dog?"
— Till Westermann, Deep Talk episode 9
A short warm-up is fine. What Lea calls "fatal" is sliding straight into personal talk after the critical point to release the tension. That mixes exactly the levels that create the friction. If something stays open, postpone it: "Let's talk again next week." How to phrase the feedback itself is covered in the article on radical candor.
3. Spend your trust credit
People promoted from within carry a trust credit but are often unaware of it, because the worry about being the bad guy dominates. Lea advises making it conscious: I have this credit, I'm allowed to do this. First, it's my role; second, my people trust me because we were a team. If you leave the credit untouched forever so as not to disappoint anyone, you lose it eventually anyway, without ever having gotten anything for it.
Frequently asked questions
How do I manage former peers or friends?
With clear roles. Clarify expectations early, separate work and personal conversations deliberately, including in time, and watch yourself for unconscious favouritism. The friendship itself is usually more robust than feared.
Will I lose friends if I'm promoted to manager?
Usually not. In a survey of more than 1,000 employees (ResumeLab, 2020), the friendship stayed the same for 69 percent and improved for 14 percent. The harder part is establishing authority in the new role.
How do I build authority as a young manager?
Not through age or volume, but through role clarity: clear expectations, reliable structures and the willingness to make unpopular decisions. Leaders promoted from within start with a trust advantage for exactly that.
How close should a manager be to their team?
There is no fixed amount. Moderate closeness was associated with less role tension in research. It becomes critical when friendship and the manager role have to be served at the same time in one conversation, or when the relationship tips entirely into friendship.
Are flat hierarchies better for startups?
Not across the board. A study of more than 6,000 video game start-ups (Lee, 2022) shows that flatter structures encourage experimentation but are more often associated with commercial failure. Without formal roles, conflicts get settled at the relationship level.
What is a blended relationship at work?
A relationship in which friendship and the working relationship overlap, for example between a manager and a report who are friends. Both have to fulfil two roles at once. Tension arises mainly when it is unclear which role applies right now.
Conclusion
Closeness is not the problem when a peer becomes a manager. It is a resource, a trust credit that carries you through unpopular decisions in particular. The risk lies where roles stay unclear: in the conversation where you have to be friend and manager at once, in expectations that were never spoken, and in structures so flat that the relationship ends up deciding everything.
In short: closeness doesn't protect you from the hard decision. It finances it.
A question for this week: if you currently manage someone who used to be your peer, which expectation should you have clarified long ago?
If you want to talk through situations like this with other new leaders going through the same thing: how the Leadership Circle works. Related: culture fit versus culture add and what makes a high performing team.
Full episode: Deep Talk episode 9, from peer to manager: closeness and distance in leadership (in German), with Lea Mersch and Till Westermann.
Sources
Hogg, M. A. (2001). A social identity theory of leadership. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 5(3), 184–200.
Hollander, E. P. (1958). Conformity, status, and idiosyncrasy credit. Psychological Review, 65(2), 117–127.
Abrams, D., Randsley de Moura, G., Marques, J. M., & Hutchison, P. (2008). Innovation credit: When can leaders oppose their group's norms? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 95(3), 662–678.
Ruef, M. (2010). The Entrepreneurial Group: Social Identities, Relations, and Collective Action. Princeton University Press.
Kovács, B., & Sels, T. (2026). Political alignment in entrepreneurial teams: Homophily in venture formation and associations with startup success. Strategic Management Journal. doi:10.1002/smj.70044
Lee, S. (2022). The myth of the flat start-up: Reconsidering the organizational structure of start-ups. Strategic Management Journal, 43(1), 58–92.
ResumeLab (2020). From BFF to Your Boss. Survey of more than 1,000 US employees. resumelab.com
Graen, G. B., & Uhl-Bien, M. (1995). Relationship-based approach to leadership: Development of leader-member exchange (LMX) theory. Leadership Quarterly, 6(2), 219–247.
Bridge, K., & Baxter, L. A. (1992). Blended relationships: Friends as work associates. Western Journal of Communication, 56(3), 200–225.
Afota, M.-C., Ollier-Malaterre, A., & Vandenberghe, C. (2024). The development of blended friendship in high leader-member exchange relationships: Mechanisms and consequences of a relational shift. Organizational Psychology Review, 14(4), 519–541.
Gallup (2025). Q2 2025 U.S. Employee Survey, n = 17,660.
Deep Talk Podcast, episode 9: From peer to manager (19 October 2026), Deep Work Club.