By Deep Work Club · Last updated: October 2026 · Reading time: 9 minutes
In scale-ups, the first layer of management usually grows out of the team itself, often faster than any programme can keep up with. At this stage many people teams have already built job levels, feedback and performance processes, and are now turning to their managers. This article compares six formats for first-time manager development, shows when each fits, which criteria help you choose a provider and how to measure whether it works. It's written for people leads, HR and founders who buy development for their leaders.
Key takeaways
In our work with leaders and people teams, new or inexperienced managers are among the topics people leads deal with most often.
No single format does everything. Training builds skills, coaching goes deep, peer groups secure transfer, offsites create a shared understanding of leadership.
Leadership training works, including on behaviour and results. A meta-analysis of 335 samples (Lacerenza et al., 2017) found it works best with a needs analysis, practice, spaced sessions and face-to-face delivery.
The bottleneck is transfer to daily work: training professionals from 150 organisations estimated that only 34 percent of training content is still applied after a year (Saks & Belcourt, 2006).
When comparing providers, look at references, demonstrable impact, fit with your company and chemistry.
Why do first-time managers in scale-ups need their own format?
First-time managers in scale-ups usually take on responsibility in the middle of growth, without a transition period and often without a role model on the level above. They were promoted for functional strength and learn leadership on the job. A dedicated format gives them the craft and a space to work through real situations before patterns set in.
We see how common this is in our work with leaders and people teams: new or inexperienced managers and building structures for growth are among the topics people leads deal with most often. Among leaders themselves, "never learned to lead" is one of the most frequent topics of all. Many people leads describe it like this:
"A large share of our leads are managing for the first time and have never learned to hand off work."
Many new managers experience their start as being thrown in at the deep end. Many scale-ups have coaching for founders, the CEO and VPs. The layer between C-level and team lead is only now getting attention, and that's exactly where first-time manager development comes in. What new leads go through in their first months is covered in the article on the first leadership role in a startup.
Which formats are there, and what do they deliver?
The six common formats are internal training, external open training, 1:1 coaching, peer groups, workshop journeys with several sessions, and offsites. They differ in how much craft they teach, how individual they are and how well learning lands in daily work. Most companies combine two or three of them.
Format | Strength | Limit | Fits especially when |
|---|---|---|---|
Internal training | Your own language and cases, scales well | Ties up internal capacity. Some topics are harder to raise openly in-house | you have many new leads at once and leadership principles are already in place |
External open training | Quick start, bookable from the learning budget | Standard content, little connection to your company, transfer is left to the individual | individual new leads need the basics |
1:1 coaching | Highly individual, confidential, goes deep | Resource-intensive per person, no comparison with others | a few key people have very individual issues |
Peer groups | Learning from real cases, commitment over months, perspectives from other companies | Less structured content, needs good facilitation | leads are alone on their level or learning needs to stick in daily work |
Workshop journey | Several training days with transfer phases, tailored to the company | Needs planning and time over several months | a whole layer of leadership should grow together |
Offsite | Shared understanding of leadership, clarity on roles and goals | Without follow-up the effect fades quickly | the leadership or core team wants to realign |
Peer groups come in two variants: internal, with leads from the same company, or cross-company, with leaders from other scale-ups. The internal variant strengthens collaboration. The cross-company variant brings perspectives that don't exist in-house and a space where leads can talk openly about topics they wouldn't raise internally. How this works in practice is described in the article on peer learning for leaders.
What does research say works?
Leadership training is considerably more effective than often assumed, including on job behaviour and results. The strongest programmes include a needs analysis, plenty of practice, feedback, multiple delivery methods and sessions spread out over time. The critical point isn't the training itself but the transfer into daily work afterwards.
The most comprehensive meta-analysis comes from Christina Lacerenza and colleagues (2017). It covers 335 independent samples and found improvements on all four of Kirkpatrick's levels: reactions, learning, transfer and results. Programmes with the features above were more effective, as was on-site, face-to-face delivery rather than self-study.
How big the transfer gap can be is shown by a survey by Alan Saks and Monica Belcourt (2006): training professionals from 150 organisations estimated that employees apply 62 percent of training content immediately after training, 44 percent after six months and 34 percent after one year. Activities in the work environment before and after training were more strongly related to transfer than activities during training.
Coaching works too: a meta-analysis by Rebecca Jones and colleagues (2016) found positive effects on organisational outcomes. Interesting for people teams: internal coaches actually performed better than external ones. External formats are therefore not an alternative to what you build in-house but a complement, especially where internal capacity is short or an outside view helps. One reason is simple: the same comment can sound like know-it-all advice from inside, and like a neutral observation from outside.
When does which format fit?
Which format fits depends on three questions: how many new managers there are right now, how similar their challenges are, and how much internal capacity you have for support. From our work with people teams and founding teams, we know typical starting situations.
Several new leads at once, for example after a growth spurt: a workshop journey with two to four training days and transfer phases in between, plus peer sessions where leads bring cases from their day-to-day.
Individual leads who are alone on their level: a cross-company peer group. It replaces the peers that don't exist in-house.
Three to five key people with very individual issues: 1:1 coaching as a starting point, often followed by a group format.
A leadership team without a shared understanding of leadership: an offsite with check-ins over six to twelve months.
Many leads, little budget per head: internal training or open courses from the learning budget, combined with a format that secures transfer.
If delegation is the most pressing topic, the article on delegation in hypergrowth is a good starting point for your leads.
How do you choose the right provider?
When choosing a provider, look at five things: credibility through references, demonstrable impact rather than attractive content, fit with your company, chemistry with decision-makers, and a proposal that convinces even without you in the room. These criteria come up again and again in our work with people teams and founding teams.
Criterion | How to check it |
|---|---|
Credibility | References from comparable companies, a conversation with former participants |
Impact over content | Can the provider explain what will change in daily work and how you'll measure it? |
Fit | Does the programme build on your principles and cases, or is it a standard package? |
Chemistry | Does the provider speak the language of your leads and your leadership team? |
Decision template | Is there a clear proposal with format, schedule and goals that the CEO or Finance can read on their own? |
Practicalities | Language (German, English), online or on-site, a cadence that survives crunch time |
For many people teams, a pure off-the-shelf offer drops out in the first round. And behind all the criteria sits one question that many ask in some form:
"What will actually change in day-to-day work, and what won't?"
How do you measure whether leadership development works?
Measure on four levels: how the programme is received, what was learned, what changes in behaviour and what shows up in the team. Before you start, define two or three changes you expect, and look again after three and six months. Without a baseline, there is nothing to compare later.
Level | Guiding question | Possible measures |
|---|---|---|
Reaction | Do the leads find the format useful? | Short survey after each session, attendance rate |
Learning | Can they do something they couldn't before? | Self-assessment before and after on specific situations |
Transfer | Do they lead differently? | Upward feedback from the team, assessment by their own manager after three months |
Results | Does it show in the team? | Engagement scores, retention of leads and their teams, fewer escalations upwards |
Three steps to get started
Clarify the need. Talk to three to five leads and their managers: which situations are hardest right now?
Pick the format by starting situation. Use the overview above and plan something that secures transfer from day one.
Set your measures. Two or three observable changes, a baseline now, a review after three months.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best format for first-time managers? There isn't one for every case. The most effective approach combines training for the craft with a format that runs over several months and secures transfer, such as peer groups or transfer phases between training days.
How long should a programme for new managers run? Spread over several months rather than packed into a few days. The meta-analysis by Lacerenza and colleagues (2017) found spaced sessions to be more effective than massed ones.
Is external coaching better than internal coaching? Not automatically. In the meta-analysis by Jones and colleagues (2016), internal coaches were actually more effective. External formats complement internal ones where capacity is short, confidentiality matters or perspectives from other companies help.
What's the difference between an internal and a cross-company peer group? In an internal group, leads from the same company learn from each other and strengthen collaboration. In a cross-company group, leaders from other companies bring new perspectives, and sensitive topics are easier to raise.
In summary
First-time managers in scale-ups learn leadership on the job. No single format covers everything, but research shows that leadership development works, especially with a needs analysis, practice and sessions spread over time. If you choose providers on impact, fit and chemistry, and define upfront what should change, you'll be able to show it later. How leaders themselves can request budget is covered in the article on getting your employer to pay for leadership coaching.
In short: the best programme is the one that keeps working after the last session.
Looking for a complement to what you've built in-house? How Deep Work sets up leadership development for growing startups and scale-ups is described on the company page. For individual leads there's the Leadership Circle: up to ten leaders from Berlin startups and scale-ups meet regularly, facilitated by Lea Mersch. Book a free intro call
Sources
Jones, R. J., Woods, S. A., & Guillaume, Y. R. F. (2016). The effectiveness of workplace coaching: A meta-analysis of learning and performance outcomes from coaching. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 89(2), 249–277. doi:10.1111/joop.12119
Lacerenza, C. N., Reyes, D. L., Marlow, S. L., Joseph, D. L., & Salas, E. (2017). Leadership training design, delivery, and implementation: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 102(12), 1686–1718. doi:10.1037/apl0000241
Saks, A. M., & Belcourt, M. (2006). An investigation of training activities and transfer of training in organizations. Human Resource Management, 45(4), 629–648. doi:10.1002/hrm.20135